Menu of Cowlick's Ice Cream Shoppe in Wolcottville, Indiana, USA

Menu Overview

Cowlick's Ice Cream Shoppe, nestled in the heart of Wolcottville, Indiana, offers a nostalgic retreat for ice cream lovers and casual diners alike. The menu is a harmonious blend of classic frozen treats and savory comfort foods, crafted to satisfy a variety of cravings all under one roof.

Starting with their ice cream offerings, Cowlick's delivers generous portions that delight with authentic, creamy textures and rich flavors. The menu features traditional sundaes priced reasonably at $4.00, with options to add extra toppings for just $0.50, allowing for personalized indulgence. For those seeking something more decadent, parfaits like the Cherry Cheesecake and Nutty Peanut Butter Chocolate stand out at $6.00 each. These are layered masterpieces where fresh, vibrant ingredients complement the smooth ice cream base, creating a balanced and memorable treat.

Noteworthy also are the Banana Split Boats, offered large for $8.00, which evoke a timeless charm and are perfect for sharing or savoring solo. Alongside these, the frappies and smoothies – such as the Caramel Frappie ($4.95) and Strawberry Banana Smoothie ($5.95) – add a refreshing dimension to the menu, combining fruit and cream in a luscious, well-blended mix.

What makes Cowlick's particularly unique is its combination of sweet delights with hearty fare that appeals to those looking for more than just ice cream. Items like the BBQ Rib Sandwich ($5.00), Chicken Bacon Subs ($7.95), Nacho Chili Cheese ($6.00), and Chili Dogs ($2.75) are flavorful, satisfying, and prepared with genuine care. These dishes provide a warm, savory counterpoint, rounding out the menu and making it a versatile spot for families and groups with varied tastes.

The atmosphere, enriched by the presence of friendly staff and a setup that recalls old-fashioned ice cream parlors, enhances the overall experience. Reports of families arriving even by horse and buggy emphasize the shop’s rooted charm and community embrace, connecting the present with nostalgia. This is echoed in customer feedback praising both product quality and the welcoming environment.

In sum, Cowlick's Ice Cream Shoppe stands out as a hidden gem offering an authentic ice cream experience along with comforting, well-priced savory options. Whether you're stopping in for a sweet treat, a hearty sandwich, or just to support a local family business finding its stride, Cowlick's promises flavor, warmth, and a slice of small-town Americana.